Think critically to analyze sources - Ten strategies for creative source engagement - The parts of ten

APA style and citations for dummies - Joe Giampalmi 2021

Think critically to analyze sources
Ten strategies for creative source engagement
The parts of ten

All sources aren’t created equal. Some sources contain a vein of gold, while others are only a chunk of coal. Here’s a tale of two sources:

· The first source explains a college admission process that includes evaluating a candidate with 95th-percentile high school grades, exceptional standardized test scores, a proficient admission essay, and participation in activities, primarily clubs.

· The second source explains a college admission process that includes evaluating a candidate with 85th-percentile high school grades, exceptional standardized test scores, a proficient admission essay, and participation in activities, primarily community service and leadership.

Essay language engaging these sources looks like this:

· Source 1: “The better candidate earned top grades and displayed time management skills and socialization skills by participating in club activities while maintaining excellent grades.”

· Source 2: “The better candidate, even though their academic scores were ten points lower, displayed people-centered activities and leadership representative of a well-rounded candidate who prioritizes helping people.”

Source engagement language that includes the author looks like this:

“From my perspective, both candidates demonstrate scholarship, time management, and participation in activities. Both candidates should be strongly considered for admission.”